PHP组合模式、策略模式

一、问题

　　模拟不同课程有不同的收费方式，并且能灵活改变(新增或删减)，如讲座可以固定收费也可改为按时收费，研讨会也是。

 

二、模式简介及关键点

1.在父类代码中使用条件语句是一种退倒，可以用多态来代替条件语句。条件语句有时被称作实现了一个“模拟继承”

2.策略模式适用于将一组算法移入到一个独立的类型中。如例子通过移走费用计算的相关代码，可以简化Lesson类型

3.在合理的模式中，Lesson类不负责计费，而是把计费任务“委托”给CostStrategy类。这种显式调用另一个对象的方法来执行一个请求的方式便是所谓的“委托”

4.让类专注自己的职责。CostStrategy负责计费，Lesson类负责管理课程数据

5.把变化的概念封装起来，本例变化的概念便是费用算法。变化的元素可被提取出来形成子类，而这些元素共同拥有一个抽象父类CostStrategy,这个类可以被其他类使用

 

三、不好的设计方式

1.定价策略被不同的子类重复实现，我们不得不重复开发功能 ，即使用if语句把定价逻辑移到父类中，也与多态替换条件的重构思想背道而驰

 

使用if语句把定价逻辑移到父类中后的结构

 

代码如下：

<?php
abstract class Lesson {
    protected $duration;
    const     FIXED = 1;
    const     TIMED = 2;
    private   $costtype;

    function __construct( $duration, $costtype=1 ) {
        $this->duration = $duration;
        $this->costtype = $costtype;
    }

    function cost() {
        switch ( $this->costtype ) {
            CASE self::TIMED :
                return (5 * $this->duration);
                break;
            CASE self::FIXED :
                return 30;
                break;
            default:
                $this->costtype = self::FIXED;
                return 30;
        }
    }

    function chargeType() {
        switch ( $this->costtype ) {
            CASE self::TIMED :
                return "hourly rate";
                break;
            CASE self::FIXED :
                return "fixed rate";
                break;
            default:
                $this->costtype = self::FIXED;
                return "fixed rate";
        }
    }

    // more lesson methods...
}

class Lecture extends Lesson {
    // Lecture-specific implementations ...
}

class Seminar extends Lesson {
    // Seminar-specific implementations ...
}

$lecture = new Lecture( 5, Lesson::FIXED );
print "{$lecture->cost()} ({$lecture->chargeType()})\n"; 

$seminar= new Seminar( 3, Lesson::TIMED );
print "{$seminar->cost()} ({$seminar->chargeType()})\n"; 
?>

　运行结果：

30 (fixed rate) 15 (hourly rate)

　　

　

四、策略模式(组合模式)-》把变化的部分(定价)封装

 

代码如下：

<?php
abstract class Lesson {
    private   $duration;
    private   $costStrategy;

    function __construct( $duration, CostStrategy $strategy ) {
        $this->duration = $duration;
        $this->costStrategy = $strategy;
    }

    function cost() {
        return $this->costStrategy->cost( $this );
    }

    function chargeType() {
        return $this->costStrategy->chargeType( );
    }

    function getDuration() {
        return $this->duration;
    }

    // more lesson methods...
}


abstract class CostStrategy {
    abstract function cost( Lesson $lesson );
    abstract function chargeType();
}

class TimedCostStrategy extends CostStrategy {
    function cost( Lesson $lesson ) {
        return ( $lesson->getDuration() * 5 );
    }
    function chargeType() {
        return "hourly rate";
    }
}

class FixedCostStrategy extends CostStrategy {
    function cost( Lesson $lesson ) {
        return 30;
    }

    function chargeType() {
        return "fixed rate";
    }
}

class Lecture extends Lesson {
    // Lecture-specific implementations ...
}

class Seminar extends Lesson {
    // Seminar-specific implementations ...
}

$lessons[] = new Seminar( 4, new TimedCostStrategy() );
$lessons[] = new Lecture( 4, new FixedCostStrategy() );

foreach ( $lessons as $lesson ) {
    print "lesson charge {$lesson->cost()}. ";
    print "Charge type: {$lesson->chargeType()}\n";
}
?>

运行结果：

lesson charge 20. Charge type: hourly rate lesson charge 30. Charge type: fixed rate

　　

　　

五、另一方面，降低耦合

代码如下：

<?php
abstract class Lesson {
    private   $duration;
    private   $costStrategy;

    function __construct( $duration, CostStrategy $strategy ) {
        $this->duration = $duration;
        $this->costStrategy = $strategy;
    }

    function cost() {
        return $this->costStrategy->cost( $this );
    }

    function chargeType() {
        return $this->costStrategy->chargeType( );
    }

    function getDuration() {
        return $this->duration;
    }

    // more lesson methods...
}


abstract class CostStrategy {
    abstract function cost( Lesson $lesson );
    abstract function chargeType();
}

class TimedCostStrategy extends CostStrategy {
    function cost( Lesson $lesson ) {
        return ( $lesson->getDuration() * 5 );
    }

    function chargeType() {
        return "hourly rate";
    }
}

class FixedCostStrategy extends CostStrategy {
    function cost( Lesson $lesson ) {
        return 30;
    }

    function chargeType() {
        return "fixed rate";
    }
}

class Lecture extends Lesson {
    // Lecture-specific implementations ...
}

class Seminar extends Lesson {
    // Seminar-specific implementations ...
}

class RegistrationMgr {
    function register( Lesson $lesson ) {
        // do something with this Lesson

        // now tell someone
        $notifier = Notifier::getNotifier();
        $notifier->inform( "new lesson: cost ({$lesson->cost()})" );
    }
}

abstract class Notifier {
    
    static function getNotifier() {
        // acquire concrete class according to 
        // configuration or other logic

        if ( rand(1,2) == 1 ) {
            return new MailNotifier();
        } else {
            return new TextNotifier();
        }
    }

    abstract function inform( $message );
}

class MailNotifier extends Notifier {
    function inform( $message ) {
        print "MAIL notification: {$message}\n";
    }
}

class TextNotifier extends Notifier {
    function inform( $message ) {
        print "TEXT notification: {$message}\n";
    }
} 
$lessons1 = new Seminar( 4, new TimedCostStrategy() );
$lessons2 = new Lecture( 4, new FixedCostStrategy() );
$mgr = new RegistrationMgr();
$mgr->register( $lessons1 );
$mgr->register( $lessons2 );

?>

　运行结果：

TEXT notification: new lesson: cost (20) MAIL notification: new lesson: cost (30)