NDK(7)NDK debugging without root access

 

from : http://ian-ni-lewis.blogspot.com/2011/05/ndk-debugging-without-root-access.html

 

NDK debugging without root access

 
Recently I made a comment to the effect that while ndk-gdb enables debugging on unrooted devices, Nvidia's Eclipse plugin and WinGDB's Visual Studio plugin don't. This means that if you want easy, IDE-based device debugging today, you need to start by running "adb root". Maybe that doesn't seem like a problem if you've already rooted your phone or if most of your debugging is done on an emulator. But if you're trying to develop on your personal phone, and it's a subsidized phone from a carrier that locks out root access, and you're trying to debug something the emulator doesn't support (cough, OpenGL 2, cough) this is kind of a big deal. Even if you've got a rooted device, why run as root if you don't have to?

This isn't meant as a criticism of either NVidia or the WinGDB folks. WinGDB has explicitly said they're only supporting emulators right now, and NVidia is targeting its own devkits that have AFAIK always shipped rooted. I highly doubt that they tried and failed to debug without root, I just don't think that they've had any real reason to try. But I was surprised to see just how small of a change needs to be made in order to enable debugging on unrooted devices.

The short answer to the question "how can I debug a process if I'm not root?" is simple: the debugger needs to run under the same account as the process it's debugging, and it can't do things (e.g. create sockets) which might be forbidden to that account. The long answer is more involved, because running under the same account isn't quite as simple as it sounds. To understand why this is tricky, let's first revisit how accounts and privileges work on Android.

When it comes to restricting privilege, desktop OSes have nothing on Android. Windows, OSX, and Linux all have the concept of root and non-root accounts, but they apply these concepts mostly to users (although both consumer OSes have followed *nix's lead in allowing sudo-style temporary privilege escalation, which while sometimes annoying, at least prevents everyone from running as root all the time). In general, every process the user runs has access to the same files and settings as any other process, give or take. Which means that "OpenOffice.exe" and "MalwareRiddenToolbarInstalledWithSomePornMyRoommateDownloaded.exe" have approximately equal ability to read, write and delete your stuff.

Android takes a different tack, one that's more common in mobile systems: it creates a different account for each app. This has two immediate advantages. First, every app gets its own "home directory" that other apps can't access, so it's harder for programs to screw with each other. Second, it makes it easy for the system to customize a set of privileges for each application. Some apps need to access the Internet, write to your contacts list, and send SMS texts; others don't.

But this compartmentalized security model makes life hard for gdbserver. While the underlying Linux permission model for debugging is pretty reasonable--as a normal user, you're allowed to debug any app that's running under the same account--that model assumes that accounts are tied to users or roles, not individual apps. What works on the desktop fails on Android because by default the app and the debugger will run under separate identities.

As an example, here's me trying to run the command line that WinGDB issued for my most recent debugging session. I'm running it against an unrooted Xperia Play. (I extracted the command line using ProcMon .)

>adb shell /data/data/com.example.testwingdb/lib/gdbserver :1001 --attach 1221
Cannot attach to process 1221: Operation not permitted (1)

No dice. The process I want to debug is running under the identity that's been assigned to com.example.testwingdb. But gdbserver is running under a different account--in this case, the default shell identity.

So what to do? Well, it turns out that there is a simple way out of this mess. Android ships with a utility called run-as. The run-as command takes a package name and a command line, then turns around and executes that command line under the security identity of the package you named. It's just like sudo, except run-as lets you specify which identity you want to run under while sudo always uses root. [Edited to add: Some Android device builds have issues with run-as. See my comment (comment #3 below this post).]

Here's me running the unix "id" command first without, then with "run-as". (For this example and the ones that follow, I'm using a package called com.example.testwingdb. If you're playing along at home, substitute your own package name.)

>adb shell id
uid=2000(shell) gid=2000(shell) groups=1003(graphics),1004(input),1007(log),1009(mount),1011(adb),1015(sdcard_rw),3001(net_bt_admin),3002(net_bt),3003(inet)

 

>adb shell run-as com.example.testwingdb id
uid=10117(app_117) gid=10117(app_117) groups=1003(graphics),1004(input),1007(log
),1009(mount),1011(adb),1015(sdcard_rw),3001(net_bt_admin),3002(net_bt),3003(inet)


So we use run-as and all is dandy, right? Not quite yet. The last part of the trick is that the executable we want to run with run-as, in this case gdbserver, needs to be in a place where our app uid has permission to execute. Sharp-eyed readers may have noted that my instance of gdbserver lives in /data/data/com.example.testwingdb/lib. Fortunately for the lazier programmers among us, it's not there by accident. It got there because ndk-build automatically puts it there when it makes a debug build. It puts it there because that's where it needs to be if you want to run it under com.example.testwingdb's uid.

With this in mind, we can make a very small tweak to the command line:
>adb shell run-as com.example.testwingdb /data/data/com.example.testwingdb/lib/gdbserver :1001 --attach 1221
Attached; pid = 1221

Woohoo!! Gdbserver is launched and has successfully attached to my process. All is perfect.... well, until this happens:

Can't bind address: Permission denied.
Exiting

Here we see the second consequence of the Android security model: apps have fine grained permissions. In this case, my app never asked for Internet permissions, so it's unable to open a socket--and because gdbserver is running under my app's uid, it can't open sockets either.

There's two ways to solve this. We could just modify our app manifest to request Internet permission. But that would suck: we don't need that permission for anything else, so we'd be making a significant change to our app's capabilities just to make it debuggable. A better solution is to do what ndk-gdb does: create a named pipe that gdbserver can use instead of a socket. Communication over named pipes doesn't require special permission as long as the pipe itself is accessible to the app, and adb includes the "forward" command that magically turns a device-side named pipe into a host-side socket:

>adb forward tcp:5039 localfilesystem:/data/data/com.example.testwingdb/debug-pipe

To use the named pipe, we launch gdbserver like this:
>adb shell run-as com.example.testwingdb /data/da
ta/com.example.testwingdb/lib/gdbserver +debug-pipe --attach 1221
Attached; pid = 1221
Listening on sockaddr socket debug-socket

And BAM. We can now connect up our favorite gdb client to port 5039 on the host, and it will communicate with the device-side instance of gdbserver over the named pipe /data/data/com.example.testwingdb/debug-pipe.

As far as I can tell, that's all it takes to enable rootless debugging. Let's review:

  1. Launch gdbserver under the uid of the process to be debugged, using run-as.
  2. Tell gdbserver to use a named pipe instead of a socket to communicate with the host.
  3. Use adb forward to forward the device-side named pipe to a host-side tcp socket.
Hope that helps!
posted @ 2015-08-17 16:22  f9q  阅读(823)  评论(0编辑  收藏  举报